Brookline vs NNHS Volleyball, Nov 13 2026
North’s Chiara Vitolo (26), Sophia Nelson (12), and Pepper Johnson (21) celebrate after winning the second set, 29-17. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
It was heartbreak for Newton North volleyball on Friday night, as the Tigers dropped a five-set thriller at rival Brookline in the quarterfinals of the MIAA Division 1 tournament.
North, the tournament’s number seven seed, used strong serving from Alyssa Teixeira, decisive outside play from Nora Hamel, and timely defense from Paige Elman to take the first two sets, 25-23 and 29-27, stunning the Warriors’ home crowd. North had only won a single set in the two previous meetings between these teams this season.
But second-seeded Brookline was determined not to surrender easily. In the next two sets, the home team leaned on its defensive skill—relentlessly chasing balls all over the court—and attacking prowess to pull even, 25-20 and 25-13, setting up a decisive fifth frame.
Again, it was North coming out hot, as the Tigers sped to a 10-2 advantage behind strong serving from Sophia Nelson and Chiara Vitolo. But Brookline roared back yet again, going on a decisive 14-4 run to win the set, 16-14.
As Brookline players jumped for joy, North players stood on their side of the court, stunned by how close they had come.
After the game, Teixeira, a junior, said that she had lots of valuable memories from the season, even if it had ended sooner than she and her teammates had wanted.
“These girls are so special to me. I love playing with them every second, every day,” she reflected. “Tiger Volley, it’s such a good community. We’re always there for each other. It’s not just a friendship through sports, it’s a friendship for life.”
MORE IMAGES
Brookline players celebrate after a remarkable come-from-behind victory over Newton North. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
North’s Pepper Johnson (21) elevates for the ball. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
North’s Isabel Holton (1) sets the ball. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
North’s Chiara Vitolo (26), Sophia Nelson (12), and Pepper Johnson (21) celebrate after winning the second set, 29-17. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
Newton North players cheer another Tiger point. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
Players and fans watch as North’s Chiara Vitolo (26) sets the ball. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
North’s Alyssa Teixeira (9) returns a serve. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
North’s Sophia Nelson (12) serves the ball in the first set. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
Fans from Brookline and Newton packed Brookline’s Schluntz Gymnasium for a heavyweight Round of 8 playoff matchup on November 13, 2026. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon
North’s Nora Hamel (18) tips the ball over the net and the Brookline defense. (c) Burt Granofsky/Newton Beacon